(Center for International Environmental Law, 25 June 2018)

A federal judge has dismissed the lawsuits introduced by San Francisco and Oakland (California) against five oil companies (BP Plc, Exxon Mobil Corp., Chevron Corp., ConocoPhillips, and Royal Dutch Shell PLC. The cities introduced the suit against these companies for knowing about climate change for decades but suppressing any action to mitigate the issue. The presiding U.S. District Judge, William Alsup, contended that while climate change is a real and serious problem, this issue should be dealt with at a higher, more global level by the political and legislative branches of the government. Alsup also stated that everyone bears blame for climate change as everyone used and benefitted from fossil fuels. However, Lisa Anne Hamilton, the Director of Climate and Energy at the Center for International Environmental Law, disagreed and said, “The dismissal of this case rests on an unfortunate belief: the false narrative that we are all equally responsible for climate change. For decades, major fossil fuel companies have known about climate change and their own contributions to it — with some, including Shell, even quantifying those contributions with surprising accuracy as early as the 1980s. Yet instead of warning the public of the dangers of fossil fuel use, these companies funded climate denial campaigns, thwarted adaptation of renewable technologies, and fought regulations while continuing to profit from the impending global crisis.